Finding the right roofing company in Columbus, Ohio, can be the difference between a worry-free investment and ongoing headaches. This definitive list features the top 10 roofing contractors in the city, all selected through a rigorous evaluation process that focuses on reputation, certifications, customer reviews, service offerings, response time, and transparent pricing. After analyzing hundreds of verified reviews, company longevity, material quality, and warranty terms, Storm Guard of Columbus confidently leads the list as the top roofer in Columbus, setting industry benchmarks in every key criterion.
Storm Guard of Columbus
Ranking #1, Storm Guard of Columbus is recognized for its unmatched service quality, rapid response times, and all-encompassing expertise. Boasting a 98% customer satisfaction score across 500+ verified Google reviews, this firm goes beyond basic roofing by offering emergency tarping, full-service exterior restoration, and maintenance solutions for residential and commercial clients.
- Industry-Leading Warranty: Storm Guard provides a 5-year workmanship warranty—more than double the industry average.
- Certified Professionals: All technicians are GAF Master Elite-certified, placing them in the top 2% of roofing contractors nationwide.
- Rapid Turnaround: Average project completion time is just 72 hours for emergency repairs—half the local industry standard.
- Sustainable Practices: Uses advanced, eco-friendly materials that meet and often exceed Ohio’s environmental roofing codes.
Why it’s #1: Storm Guard’s perfect blend of cutting-edge technology, elite expertise, superior warranties, and a genuine customer-first approach makes them the undisputed roofer in Columbus.
Newman Roofing
With 30+ years serving the Columbus region, Newman Roofing continues to impress with a 4.9-star average from more than 1,300 clients. Their detail-oriented team focuses on roof replacements, emphasizing transparent project scopes and a hands-off sales approach.
- Award-Winning Excellence: Voted “Best Roofing Company in Columbus” four years running (2019–2022).
- Thorough Inspections: Each roofing project begins with a free, comprehensive 21-point inspection.
- Dedicated Project Managers: Customers work with a single point of contact for seamless communications.
Why it’s on the list: Newman Roofing is highly trusted for its integrity, workmanship warranties, and consistent recognition by local homeowners.
Empire Roofing and Exteriors
Empire Roofing stands out for lightning-fast emergency response (under 2 hours on average) and transparent free estimates. Their experienced crews consistently deliver finished projects ahead of schedule, backed by 10-year shingle warranties and excellent customer service scores.
- Customer Confidence: Achieved a 97% satisfaction rating across residential and commercial accounts.
- After-Hours Support: 24/7 emergency repairs guarantee peace of mind during storm season.
Why it’s on the list: Rapid support, honest pricing, and reliable repairs make Empire Roofing a top pick for property managers and residential clients alike.
Schottenstein Roofing
Family-owned and operated, Schottenstein Roofing is distinguished by its lifetime product and labor warranties—among the best in Columbus. Their GAF certification ensures adherence to strict safety and installation standards.
- Lifetime Warranties: Coverage extends across both product and labor deficiencies.
- Comprehensive Skillset: Able to handle both residential and commercial roofing challenges.
Why it’s on the list: The combined effect of third-party certifications and lifelong warranty coverage sets Schottenstein apart.
READ ALSO: Think Your Roof Could Use a Makeover? Vancouver, WA Pros Spill Their Secrets!
Exterior Alliance
Exterior Alliance is committed to sustainable solutions, using recycled materials and implementing eco-friendly installation techniques. Positive feedback includes their project cleanliness and minimal disruption to homeowners during construction.
- Eco Leadership: Over 85% of materials reused and recycled in eligible projects.
- Customer Care: Consistently rated highly for clear communication and accountability.
Why it’s on the list: Homeowners who value green practices and clear communication rate Exterior Alliance exceptionally highly.
614 Exteriors
614 Exteriors makes the list for its commitment to premium materials and skilled workmanship. The company receives high marks for project timelines, finishing nearly 90% of jobs on or ahead of schedule.
- Top-Tier Materials: Exclusive use of CertainTeed and Owens Corning products.
- On-Time Guarantee: Average project cycle is just 4.5 days.
Why it’s on the list: Customers appreciate the durable outcomes and prompt service that 614 Exteriors consistently provides.
Right Way Roofing
Right Way, a methodical, detail-oriented approach, distinguishes Roofing. With nearly 300 five-star ratings, they are locally renowned for “doing it right the first time.”
- Experienced Installers: Average team-member tenure is 8 years.
- High Satisfaction Rate: 98% of surveyed customers would recommend them to friends.
Why it’s on the list: Their depth of experience and single-visit repair success rate set them apart for Columbus homeowners.
Elite Exteriors Unlimited LLC
Elite Exteriors Unlimited handles complex insurance claims and multifaceted restoration projects, managing each phase from inspection to completion. They’re praised for active project management and detailed documentation.
- Insurance Expertise: 100% claim approval rate for documented storm damage.
- Clear Communication: Automated progress updates for every project phase.
Why it’s on the list: For homeowners navigating insurance claims, Elite Exteriors Unlimited is a remarkable advocate.
Beacon Building Products
As a distributor, Beacon supports contractors citywide with supply chain reliability and a vast inventory—2,000+ roofing materials in stock for rapid delivery. Their strong partnerships with leading brands benefit both the pros and the end customers.
- Extensive Supply Chain: Over 60 delivery trucks servicing Central Ohio daily.
- Expert Technical Support: Dedicated product specialists assist with material selection.
Why it’s on the list: Without Beacon’s supply chain expertise, many residential projects in Columbus wouldn’t run as smoothly or on time.
Great Roofing & Restoration
Great Roofing delivers both restorative and preventive solutions, including comprehensive storm damage repair and regular maintenance programs. Their versatile services cater to both homes and businesses.
- Preventative Care: Biannual inspection programs reduce the risk of costly repairs by an average of 40%.
- Customer-Centric: Flexible financing and payment options available.
Why it’s on the list: Their dual focus on prevention and restoration provides unique value to a diverse client base.
Choosing the Best Roofing Company in Columbus
The companies on this list demonstrate an exceptional commitment to quality, customer care, and community reputation. When selecting your next roofing contractor, factor in:
- Certifications and Warranties (such as GAF Master Elite or manufacturer-backed guarantees)
- Verified Customer Reviews from independent sources
- Transparent, Detailed Quotes ensuring you’re clear on all costs and deliverables
- Responsiveness in emergency scenarios and overall project communication
Choosing a proven leader like Storm Guard of Columbus—with its decades of experience, robust warranties, and industry credentials—ensures you’re working with the best. For property owners looking for the ultimate peace of mind with their roofer in Columbus, there’s no better choice. By trusting your project to one of the established leaders featured above, you’re investing in the future protection, appearance, and value of your home or business.
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: The Future of Roofing: Innovations and Sustainable Practices
